Home » Articles » Justice: Why Love Can’t Survive Without It

Justice: Why Love Can’t Survive Without It

by Dr. Eitan Bar
6 minutes read

From the outset, justice has been a prominent recurring motif. Discussions on justice appear early in the Torah (e.g., Leviticus 19:15) and are also emphasized by the prophets (e.g., Micah 6:8). In the intricate dance of human interactions, love and justice are often seen as partners whose steps occasionally misalign. While many perceive these forces as distinct or even opposing, a deeper examination reveals that they are profoundly interdependent, each essential to the full expression and existence of the other. Justice manifests in both personal relationships and societal structures, revealing that a true understanding of love is incomplete without a commitment to justice.

Justice as an Expression of Love

Justice, at its core, involves ensuring that everyone receives what they are rightfully due—whether it pertains to rights, opportunities, or resources. In a loving relationship, this principle translates into fair, respectful, and considerate actions of each person’s needs and boundaries. Without a foundation of justice, actions that claim to be motivated by love can easily become unbalanced, leading to dependency, resentment, or even abuse, with marriages being a classic example.1

In a broader societal context, justice allows love to extend beyond the confines of individual relationships to encompass community and societal relationships. For example, the principles driving social justice movements are usually rooted in ensuring that every individual is treated with dignity and respect—a clear manifestation of extending love to the broader human family. Efforts to combat racism, poverty, and inequality are fueled by a vision of a more loving society where everyone has the opportunity to thrive. This approach to justice underlines the idea that true love is inherently inclusive and equitable, actively seeking the well-being of all, not just those with whom one shares immediate or superficial connections.

The Crucial Role of Trust

Trust is a critical component of any loving relationship, serving as the infrastructure upon which emotional security is built. However, for trust to develop and sustain itself, the presence of justice is essential. In just relationships, promises are kept, contributions are recognized, and errors are gracefully acknowledged and forgiven. On the other hand, injustice erodes trust, creating an atmosphere filled with suspicion and fear—conditions under which love cannot survive, let alone flourish.

Biblical Justice

From a theological standpoint, the scriptures provide a rich tapestry of references illuminating the inseparable connection between justice and love. The Bible often and explicitly states that justice is a divine requirement and that just behavior among humans directly reflects divine love. This theological perspective does not segregate love and justice into separate categories but intertwines them, portraying justice as an act of love towards one’s neighbor, ensuring they are treated with the dignity they deserve.

From the beginning, the Hebrew Scriptures strongly emphasize justice as central to God’s character and His expectations for human conduct. Rather than merely adhering to laws, biblical justice is portrayed as integral to righteousness, reflecting God’s holy and just nature. It involves fairness, equity, and compassion, particularly towards the vulnerable and marginalized in society—such as the poor, widows, orphans, and strangers. For instance, the laws given to Moses extensively cover aspects of fairness and equity, prohibiting partiality and ensuring fair treatment for all, including foreigners and servants. Prophets like Amos, Isaiah, and Micah vehemently denounce injustices and demand social equity, emphasizing that true worship of God cannot be separated from the practice of justice.

In the New Testament, Christ further exemplifies and deepens the theme of justice as an expression of love and mercy. He challenges societal norms that oppress the vulnerable and advocates for a justice that transcends mere legalism, aiming instead at restoration and reconciliation. Through parables and teachings, Jesus illustrates that divine justice involves active compassion and practical help for those in need. His approach sets a standard that merges justice with mercy in a transformative manner that points towards the Kingdom of God.

Ultimately, justice amplifies love, making it active and transformative. Love devoid of action towards justice can become superficial, a sentiment that fails to address the real needs or hurts of others. True love compels us to engage deeply with the world and its issues, driving us toward acts of justice that seek to heal, restore, and build.

The necessity for justice in expressions of love is starkly evident in contexts where it is absent. In environments riddled with injustice, love struggles to establish itself, as individuals find it difficult to feel loved while they are simultaneously oppressed or marginalized. Thus, justice is not merely a companion to love but its enabler, creating environments where love can genuinely flourish.

As we expand this discussion to a global scale, the interconnection between love and justice becomes even more significant. In an increasingly interconnected world, our actions—or inactions—can have far-reaching impacts. The principle of justice ensures that love is not confined by geographical boundaries but is extended to all humanity, recognizing the inherent dignity and worth of every person, regardless of nationality, ethnicity, or economic status.

Global challenges such as poverty and human rights violations call for a response that is grounded in both love and justice. For instance, addressing pollution is not just an environmental duty but also an act of love toward future generations and vulnerable populations disproportionately affected by it. Similarly, the fight against poverty and human rights is deeply tied to the biblical injunction to love our neighbor. These are not merely social or political issues; they are profound moral imperatives that require us to apply our understanding of love and justice in practical, far-reaching ways.

Justice as Restoration and Reconciliation

One of the most powerful aspects of biblical justice is its capacity for restoration and reconciliation. Biblical justice is not about retribution but about restoring harmony. This concept is vividly illustrated in the ministry of Jesus, who came to “proclaim good news to the poor… and to set the oppressed free” (Luke 4:18). His sook to restore individuals into a relationship with God, reflecting the ultimate vision of justice as a restorative rather than punitive process.

In practical terms, this means advocating for systems and structures that not only correct wrongs but also restore individuals to full community membership. This could involve supporting rehabilitative rather than merely punitive criminal justice systems, advocating for economic systems that allow for genuine opportunity for all, and fostering cultural attitudes that value reconciliation and healing over division and strife.

If love is the motivation, justice is the action. In our personal lives, this can manifest in numerous ways—from how we handle conflicts in relationships to how we participate in community and societal structures. Practicing justice in our personal sphere might involve actively listening to and addressing the needs and concerns of our partners, friends, and family members. It requires us to be fair and equitable in our dealings, whether in sharing resources or in giving time and attention.

Seeking justice does not entail boycotting, excommunication, ostracism, or canceling individuals, as is often practiced in religious cults. Rather, it involves striving to stop and repair the wrongs done and restore and reconcile individuals and relationships.

On a societal level, love motivated by justice pushes us to engage with our communities—whether by volunteering, participating in civic life, or supporting policies and leaders who champion justice. It calls us to be active participants in shaping a society that reflects our deepest values of fairness, equity, and compassion.

Conclusion

By embedding justice into our conceptual framework of love, we redefine the dynamics of our interactions. This integrated perspective challenges us not merely to speak of love on social platforms but to enact it in ways that affirm the worth and dignity of every individual we come in touch with. In doing so, justice and love together create a synergy that has the power to transform society. Through this lens, we see that just as love without justice is incomplete, so too is justice without love. Loveless justice becomes mechanical, perhaps even harsh, lacking the warmth and empathy that love naturally infuses into acts of fairness and equity, reflecting that our God is a Father, not a tyrant. Thus, the integration of justice with love not only enhances our relationships but also enriches the very essence of how we understand and practice both concepts.

This article is from the book, “The Theology of Love: Christianity’s Most Underrated Doctrine.

  1. For a further discussion on justice, love, and abuse in marriages, see my book, “Christian and Divorced: What the Bible REALLY Says About Divorce & Remarriage↩︎

You may also like:

Dr. Eitan Bar
Author, Theologian, Activist