“If Jesus were the Messiah,” the argument goes, “the front page would announce world peace. Isaiah says wolves and lambs will live together — yet history after Jesus looks bloody, not blissful.” That objection deserves a careful, Jewishly literate reply. Scripture does bind the Messiah and shalom (Hebrew for peace) together, but it does so in a story with stages. The prophets paint both a suffering figure who is rejected and dies, and a royal figure who judges evil and establishes universal peace. The wise question is not, “Peace yet?” but, “In God’s sequence, which part of the Messiah’s work has already begun — and what still awaits completion?”
One Messiah, Two Movements
Hebrew Scripture loves patterns. Joseph then David; humiliation then exaltation; exile then return. The messianic portrait follows the same rhythm. Early Jewish sources noticed this tension and posed it in memorable ways: will the Messiah come “lowly and riding on a donkey” (Zechariah 9:9), or “with the clouds of heaven” (Daniel 7:13–14)? Some sages answered: it depends — if Israel merits, he comes in glory; if not, in humility. Either way, the texts themselves present one figure with two modes of appearing: first to suffer and be hidden, then to reign and be revealed.
That’s precisely the shape of Yeshua’s mission as the earliest Jewish disciples understood it. In his first coming he embodies the “Messiah son of Joseph” pattern — despised, pierced, giving himself for the life of the world. In his return he will fully unveil the “Messiah son of David” pattern — judging evil and bringing the wolf-and-lamb peace Isaiah saw. Two roles, one Messiah; two acts, one drama.
What Peace Looks Like in the Prophets
Isaiah and his peers speak of shalom on several horizons:
Moral and spiritual peace: hearts reconciled to God (new covenant; forgiveness; law written on hearts).
Social peace: enemies reconciled, swords hammered into plowshares (Isaiah 2:4).
Cosmic peace: creation itself healed — predator and prey at rest (Isaiah 11:6–9).
The prophets never say the moment Messiah appears all three horizons arrive at once. Instead they show a stream that widens: the knowledge of the LORD begins to cover the land “as the waters cover the sea,” (Habakkuk 2:14) not as a flash flood but as an unstoppable tide.
What Has Already Begun
If the Messianic peace is staged, what should we expect now?
• Peace with God (vertical): By his self-offering, Yeshua brings atonement that cleanses the conscience and reconciles sinners to the Holy One. That is real peace, not metaphor: estranged hearts brought home.
• Peace within (interior): “My peace I give to you; not as the world gives.” The Messiah does not start by rearranging geopolitics; he remakes persons. His Spirit quiets the storm inside long before the storms of nations cease.
• Peace across hostility (horizontal): From the beginning, the gospel creates one new family out of Jew and Gentile. People who would never share a table share one bread. This is not the final chapter of Isaiah 2 — but it is its firstfruits.
• Peace that grows: Yeshua likened his kingdom to yeast working through dough, a seed becoming a tree. That is not failure; it is design. Peace spreads person by person, household by household, people by people, until the King returns to complete what has begun.
Why Rabbinic Voices Diverge on “When” and “How”
If you survey rabbinic literature, you’ll find a chorus of hopes rather than a single script: some place conditions on Messiah’s arrival (national repentance, faithful sabbaths), some call the messianic figure a king, others speak of an era, still others identify the role with particular leaders. The diversity itself testifies to the textual tension: Scripture promises a pierced one, a purifier who judges, and a prince of peace. Without the key of “one Messiah in two movements,” these threads can feel contradictory. With that key, they harmonize: suffering and sacrifice first; judgment and universal shalom next.
Suffering First — Deeply Jewish, Utterly Messianic
Long before Yeshua, Jewish expectation included a suffering redeemer. Many midrashic and mystical texts speak of a Messiah who bears sorrows, accepts sufferings for Israel, and even dies — language grounded in Isaiah 53 and echoed in Zechariah 12. The point is not to score citations, but to show that the idea of messianic suffering is not foreign to Judaism. It arises from the same Scriptures we are reading together. In that light, Yeshua’s cross is not a detour away from peace; it is the bridge toward it.
Why Peace Could Not Come “All at Once” Without Judgment
Shalom is not mere ceasefire; it is wholeness married to justice. If the King were to impose cosmic peace today without reckoning with evil, the result would be a pretty mask on a diseased face. The prophets are clear: when the Branch of David reigns, he “strikes the earth with the rod of his mouth… with righteousness he shall judge the poor, and decide with equity” (Isaiah 11:4). Judgment is not the cancellation of peace; it is its necessary surgery. In his first coming, Yeshua bore our sins so mercy could spread. In his return, he will remove remaining evil so peace can remain.
Answering the Headline Objection
“Two thousand years of wars — how can you call that messianic?” Three replies:
The prophets never promised an instant utopia at Messiah’s first appearing. They promised a decisive forgiveness and a Spirit-poured renewal that would grow until the King returns. That is what we see: the Scriptures translated into thousands of tongues, the God of Abraham embraced across the nations, hospitals and orphanages and movements of mercy rooted in the teachings of the Nazarene. Not perfection—firstfruits.
The Messiah’s peace is “not as the world gives.” He refused to seize thrones by the sword; he conquered by the cross. History’s wars indict human hearts, not the Messiah’s mission.
The continued ache for peace is itself a signpost. The story is not over. The wolf-and-lamb vision is not discarded; it is reserved for the fuller unveiling of the King.
The Two Signs — Donkey and Clouds — Held Together
Zechariah’s humble king rides into Jerusalem on a donkey; Daniel’s Human One rides the clouds to receive universal dominion. The gospels present Yeshua doing the first and promising the second. To dismiss him for not yet doing the clouds is to reject the scriptural order. To embrace him for the donkey is to ready oneself for the clouds.
Why the Messiah Must First Make Peace With God
If the deepest war is between holy love and our rebellious hearts, then the first victory must be won there. That is why the Servant bears sin, why the shepherd lays down his life for the sheep, why a new covenant has to be written on hearts. Once that peace is established, the rest will follow — not because humans will finally evolve into angels, but because the King will return to make on earth what is already true in heaven.
A Jewish Peacemaker: Crucified, Risen, and Alive
This is not pagan apotheosis or gentle philosophy. It is the God of Israel keeping His promises in Israel’s Messiah for Israel and the nations. A Joseph-like Savior suffers to save his brothers; a David-like King then rules to heal the world. That pattern is ours. Yeshua’s resurrection is the pledge that peace will not end with good intentions. The tomb is empty; the throne is not.
What We Can Say Now — and What We Await
Now: forgiveness for enemies; courage for peacemaking; the Spirit’s power to reconcile.
Awaiting: the visible reign where “they shall not hurt or destroy in all my holy mountain; for the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the LORD as the waters cover the sea” (Isaiah 11:9). The first is already offered; the second is already promised.
A gentle word to the skeptic: If the only Messiah you can accept is one who ends war instantly by force (and how would that work—by killing everyone?), you’ll overlook the Messiah who abolishes enmity by loving enemies, both in this life and for eternity. The wolf and the lamb will lie down together. But first, the wolf in me must lie down, and the lamb of God must rise. That is why he came. That is why he will come again.
Conclusion
The absence of world peace does not refute Yeshua’s messiahship; it locates us between his two messianic roles. He has made peace by the blood of his cross, and he will make peace by the scepter of his justice. Receive the first, and you are made ready for the second: “Peace I leave with you; my peace I give to you. Not as the world gives do I give to you.” (John 14:27)
If you found this article thought-provoking, you’ll find much more in my best-selling book, Refuting Rabbinic Objections to Christianity & Messianic Prophecies:
