Home » There’s Something Wrong if Your Theology Never Changes

There’s Something Wrong if Your Theology Never Changes

by Dr. Eitan Bar
3 minutes read

The Bible is the foundation and Truth we extract and develop theological concepts from. Theology can be approached from two distinct perspectives. One viewpoint is rooted in the idea that all essential theological understanding has already been revealed. Proponents of this perspective value the wisdom and insights of early Church Fathers or Fathers of the Reformation, considering their teachings as the ultimate resource for theological inquiry. In this view, studying theology involves delving into past wisdom to gain a thorough understanding of divine truth.

Contrastingly, the alternate perspective assumes that our understanding of divine truth is a continually unfolding process. Advocates of this viewpoint posit that while there is much to learn from the past, not all truths about God have been fully unveiled yet. This viewpoint sees theology as a dynamic, evolving discipline that continually uncovers new layers of understanding about the divine.

These two contrasting worldviews define different approaches to theological study – one that looks primarily to the past for definitive understanding and the other that embraces the journey of discovery, looking forward to the insights yet to be revealed.

I believe that the principles of growth and progression should not be limited to disciplines such as science, art, and psychology. Theology, as a study and interpretation of religious texts and beliefs, can, is, and should be subject to evolution. The following points highlight why this evolution is not just likely, but also necessary and beneficial.

  1. Human logic evolves alongside our theological understanding: We live in the information age as knowledge is widely available to most people in the West. As human comprehension evolves, certain traditional theological perspectives may no longer provide adequate answers. For instance, the enduring question of God’s sovereignty versus human free will has prompted the emergence of fresh theological theories. Molinism is one such theory, reflecting the need for theology to evolve in response to our progressing understanding.
  2. Expanding Understanding of the Divine: Theology, at its core, seeks to comprehend the divine and spiritual realm. This understanding is never static – it evolves as societies and cultures change. Martin Luther’s theological revolution during the Reformation period serves as a classic example of this evolution. He challenged long-standing doctrines of the Church, leading to a profound shift in Christian theology. In more recent times, the evolution of theology has involved questioning and reinterpreting traditional understandings of the divine in light of modern-day issues such as racial justice and environmental stewardship. With each new generation, fresh perspectives and insights emerge, leading to a more nuanced and enriched understanding of spiritual matters.
  3. Interdisciplinary Influence: The interplay between theology and fields like history, linguistics, and archaeology significantly enriches our understanding of religious texts and contexts. Historical research illuminates the cultural and societal backdrop of theological narratives, enhancing our grasp of their meaning. Archaeology provides tangible evidence of past civilizations, furthering our knowledge of the milieu within which religious events unfolded. This intertwining of disciplines shapes our interpretation of religious texts and helps us understand their original contexts more deeply.
  4. Cultural Relevance: Theology cannot afford to be detached from cultural changes; it must reflect and respond to them. A potent example of this is the emergence of liberation theology in Latin America during the 20th century. This theological approach, born out of socio-political unrest, sought to highlight the role of Christian theology in fighting poverty and social injustice. Slavery in America was another example.
  5. Addressing New Ethical Challenges: Today’s world presents us with unprecedented ethical challenges. Technological advancements such as genetic engineering and artificial intelligence have opened up new avenues of human potential, yet they also pose significant ethical dilemmas. Climate change and environmental degradation raise urgent questions about our stewardship of the planet, requiring us to revisit theological teachings on the human-nature relationship. Social justice movements highlight systemic inequalities that demand a robust theological response.
  6. Increased Inclusivity: The evolution of theology plays a critical role in promoting inclusivity. Traditional theological interpretations have often been critiqued for their patriarchal bias and lack of representation of diverse experiences. Furthermore, interfaith dialogue (especially between Christianity and Judaism) caused many to investigate the Jewish roots of their faith and find new and exciting truths.

In essence, the evolution of theology is crucial. As science, art, and psychology adapt to new understandings, so must theology. This progression ensures that our comprehension of the divine deepens, making theology relevant and responsive to our evolving world. The interplay with other disciplines necessitates this evolution, as theology integrates new insights and tackles fresh questions. Rather than threatening faith, this dynamism affirms theology’s resilience and adaptability, underscoring its enduring relevance in our ever-evolving human narrative.

You may also like:

Dr. Eitan Bar
Author, Theologian, Activist